TheStub said:
Without focusing on this player or that player, can someone give me an honest run down on how we played?
What tactics did we use? How effective were our match ups? What match ups were we going for?
I hate missing games
To me it seemed the same as every game I've seen his season - a low intensity start with players just going through the motions and a 'token' forecheck.
As Rempel quite rightly says, things changed followed by Frank's hit in the Giants zone which sparked Voth into a hit which shock horror forced a turnover and a chance out front.
Another forecheck with intent then quickly resulted in another turnover and good chance out front. For a moment it seemed that the team had suddenly realised what we all know - that a strong forecheck brings us success on home ice.
Unfortunately it didn't continue and we moved into the second period where Frank had his moment with Bannister following a scuffle and some chippy play prior. Obviously I've only seen it in real time so would rather wait for a reply before committing to a call, but on first look Frank should be looking at 4 games. He's lucky the league botched the ruling on Doucet so with that precedent shouldn't get any more than the one he has. I want Frank to be a success and he obviously has the ability, but too often the bloke seems to make bad choices (and I still haven't see him throw a legal hit
)
The third period we seemed devoid of ideas as Braehead took the lead and stacked the neutral zone. It seemed obvious that we should have been dumping and chasing hard to win turnovers (particularly with Braehead short on D and Banister likely not at 100%) - instead we tried to skate the puck through the Braehead wall with our chronic lack of skill
Unfortunate for Max at the end who was one of our better players and was one of few who tried to inject some energy into the Devils, but it just shows how you have to stay witched on in the pro arena. He made a bad decision in our own end and it cost us.
In terms of the lines...I'm struggling to see where Dobben fits in. He's not physical enough for the third line and not skillfull enough for the big line. A similar story for Macrae as well, who's style of game isn't enough to get Pearce skating. Matzka off his game offensively, but wasted on a line with Voth (who doesn't seem bothered) and Hill (forgotten how to hit and shoot)
In summary (IMO of course);
Physical for short periods which worked
Back to non-contact hockey for the majority
Chronic lack of skill/team chemistry
Bad decision-making
Good goaltending
Questionable tactics in the third