the outcome of fights are nearly always argued over, and each teams set of fans have their own opinions.
the fight was between 2 tough players, both fought well and landed some good punches, and it could be argued for a long time who landed the most and best punches , and despite the cut above Keefe's doesnt nessesarily make Batch the winner (how many times was Voth cut and win fights in the past
) you call a Batch win, Giants call a Keefe win, personally i would say a good draw, but certainly a marker now laid down by Batch that he will now have to live up to in every game no matter who the opposition is