It's probably still too soon for me to give a considered view on which of the players should be re-signed for next season stop. That was such an awful performance against Coventry that my gut reaction is probably very different to my considered one.
Still, here's my two pence worth;
Definitely -
Bowns - no explanation needed here. He is probably the most valuable player in the league as a British netminder who can hold his own against any of the imports.
Richardson - for me, the best and most consistent defenceman on our team. Not only that, but is arguably the best British defenceman in the league as well. Here is a must have for me.
Batch - ever-improving, hard as nails and British. A definite for me.
Martin - no explanation needed here really. The top points scorer in the league, the best playmaker in the league, and a player who works hard every night and epitomises what the devils are all about.
Fournier - with the opportunity to play a full season on the big ice, I think Fournier will prove to be one of the best defencemen in the league. He has the offensive capabilities of Hudson and Hotham, but I think he makes fewer errors than either.
Hendrikx - his first pass is superb, he hits hard and sticks up for him team. I'd make him captain and line him with someone quick and offensively minded.
Doucet - hard-working, skilful goalscorer who, like Martin, plays with the Devils mentality. Good in the clutch too, so I'd keep him on that basis.
Probably / Maybe -
Hervato - I like his energy, and his determination. I think I'd keep him on that basis, but I could see an argument for a bigger, tougher version.
Haddad - he hits, scores and holds the puck up well. I like him as a power forward, but might be tempted to test the market for a Szwez player who brings similar skills and toughness as well.
Russell - has scored a point of game, but I was surprised when I read that. Because I was surprised, I wonder if perhaps he's not offering as much as I thought he would. Hard one to call really, but I think I'd keep him.
Mo - solid player, and we do need points to come from somewhere. I'd be tempted to keep him, but only if the price is right. He's not a first line player in my opinion.
Probably not -
Salters - I desperately wanted him to succeed, and he will probably go somewhere else and dominate when 100% fit. He never seemed to be settled in Cardiff, and perhaps that was a factor. If we can sign a McGrattan or Bissonnette standard player, the decision to release him probably becomes easier.
Kurka - I might get challenged on this one, but I never felt that he made a huge difference this year. When we were losing, he wasn't the one that I was looking to. On the basis that he's probably very expensive, I wonder if we can do better? That said, if he can settle on a line, his pace will be valuable on the big ice.
Hudson / Hotham - I'd keep one of them - undecided as to which. They need a solid, no-nonsense partner and they need to understand their role. We have enough points in the forwards - protect their zone first and foremost.
Culligan - unless they find a specific role for him, he might not be the best fit. That said, he's versatile and might have a place in the team with the rise in import levels.
Overall, I think most of the team could stake a claim for place next season. Without clear lines, and better tactics, I don't think it will matter who the Devils put out on the ice.