Sorry Paul, no hairs to split, you worded you post badly simple as that
( and then attempt to patronise me by writing ''So. Let's try this'' )
You ask me can I name two defencemen in either the 2010/11 or 2011/12 seasons that have consistently played better than G? I have already have i.e Richie and Kenton! ( and I have taken into account your point about the whole season) I haven't mentioned Weller = you did - as he didn't play for 2 seasons, so why would you bring that into the debate?
Also, I have am certainly not making an assumption rather than a factually based comment. I respect your opinion, but it is your opinion, not mine ( you obviously don't appreciate my opinion, thats clear to see, but I am after all entitled to it)
Your final paragraph, quote.
I do not blindly advocate or promote the club or whoever is in a certain position for the sake of it. However I have a lot of respect for G and having seen him from a professional perspective up close I make my comments from a solid point of reference, not a rose-tinted bandstand.
I've no argument with that at all, you really must get off that high horse of yours now and again and don't make assumptions of others!!