He played well today and has had a great season for Dundee but he's a skilled, top 6 forward in the roster, playing PP minutes etc. He's not really going to do a job on your 3rd or 4th lines, not that grinding kind of player. Post Ulmer and Bentivoglio being split and the way they've played since then, I still wouldn't swap one of our top 6 forwards (Martin, Bentivoglio, Lord, Ulmer, Haddad, Asselin) for Scarsella. It's not just about skill and attacking play, but defensive responsibility and all round contribution. And next year, we are going to need to upgrade if we can on what we have had this year. I think most would agree there's a big difference between the conferences and the scoring charts are skewed because of it, as are the all star line ups. Back to the title of this thread - it's unbelievable that Joey Haddad isn't in one of those first and second all star line ups, yet players like Beca and Pitt are because they've probably scored a shed load of points playing the weaker Gardiner teams.